Barstool Sports: The Digital Media Network That Sold Twice And Came Home

Barstool Sports is the digital sports media network founded in 2003 by Dave Portnoy as a print gambling newspaper in Boston. Over two decades, it evolved into one of the largest independent sports and comedy digital networks in the United States — a portfolio of dozens of podcasts, video franchises, live events, merchandise, and personalities under one operating brand. Its two sale transactions — first to Chernin Group in 2016, then to Penn Entertainment in 2020–2023 — and the January 2023 buyback by Portnoy for one dollar, form the most-cited digital-media transaction sequence of the last decade.

The two sales and the one-dollar buyback

The Chernin Group acquisition of a majority stake in 2016 valued Barstool at approximately $10–15 million. Peter Chernin's team scaled the business as a digital-first operator with heavy podcast programming. In January 2020, Penn Entertainment (formerly Penn National Gaming) acquired a 36% stake for $163 million as part of a sports-betting strategy, then bought out the remaining stake in February 2023 at a total valuation of roughly $551 million across the two tranches. Six months later, in August 2023, Penn sold the business back to Portnoy for one dollar plus a share of any future sale proceeds. The reason: casino-license regulatory friction that Barstool's content style — Portnoy's on-camera character, in particular — was making impossible to resolve.

The network of podcasts

The Barstool podcast portfolio is the operating asset. Pardon My Take — hosted by Dan "Big Cat" Katz and PFT Commenter — is the flagship, one of the top comedy-sports podcasts in the country since its 2016 launch. Call Her Daddy originated at Barstool in 2018 with Alex Cooper and Sofia Franklyn before Cooper departed for the Spotify exclusive in 2021 and later moved to SiriusXM. Bussin' With The Boys with Will Compton and Taylor Lewan. The Dave Portnoy Show. KFC Radio. The Rundown for daily news. Barstool Sports Advisors for gambling. Dozens more across sub-brands. Barstool built the podcast-network-as-business model before any legacy media company caught up.

The Portnoy face-of-brand structure

Portnoy's on-camera identity — direct, confrontational, willing to break controversy — is both the growth engine and the acquisition friction. His One Bite pizza reviews, the Davey Day Trader Global stock content during 2020, and the recurring political and cultural commentary have kept Barstool at the center of mainstream press cycles for a decade. That volatility is why the Penn deal ultimately could not survive gaming regulation. It is also why the one-dollar buyback was structured with Portnoy back in operating control — the personality-driven format cannot be run at scale without the founder personality attached. For communications teams studying the case, Barstool is the reference for founder-brand risk both as accelerant and as governance ceiling.

Why Barstool matters for brand teams

For brand teams, Barstool is the reference case for the sports-comedy audience that broadcast networks and legacy sports media have not been able to reach at scale. Young-male attention economics, gambling-adjacent content, comedy timing, and podcast-native distribution combine to produce a media asset that competes with — and often outperforms — ESPN on specific programming. Pardon My Take advertisers, from DraftKings to Bud Light to Chevy, have used the Barstool network as the closest thing digital media offers to appointment-viewing sports television. For talent, Barstool has served as the on-ramp — Alex Cooper's Call Her Daddy origin, Pat McAfee's early affiliation before the ESPN move — that produced the highest-earning individual podcast operators of the current cycle.

Related coverage: Podcasts as Marketing: Spotify, Apple, and Joe Rogan · Top 10 Sports Influencers · The Creator Economy