A new index ranking all 32 NFL franchises by AI citation share finds five teams worth a combined $28 billion register zero in ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini, and Google AI Overviews. The Dallas Cowboys take 39% of all citations. The Super Bowl champion ranks 12th.
The first AI visibility index of professional sports — released today by 5W — has surfaced what may be the largest unmeasured mispricing in the sponsorship market.
According to The 5W NFL Citation Share Index 2026, five NFL franchises — the New York Jets, New Orleans Saints, Indianapolis Colts, Arizona Cardinals, and Minnesota Vikings — register a Citation Share Score of zero. Their combined enterprise value, per Forbes' 2025 franchise valuations, exceeds $28 billion.
The Index measures how often each franchise appears, and where it ranks in the response, when an AI engine answers any of 50 standardized prompts across four buckets — fan, sponsor, free agent, and business. Each prompt was run three times across five AI engines to control for variance. Total: 750 queries. The verbatim methodology and prompt list were published alongside the Index, alongside a downloadable CSV dataset.
The findings cut against several years of conventional sponsorship valuation logic.
The Jets, valued at $10 billion-plus and ranked sixth-most-valuable in the league, scored 28th on AI citation share. The gap — 22 positions between valuation and visibility — is the largest in the league. Similar gaps appear at Washington (Commanders) and Chicago (Bears), where the Forbes ranking significantly outpaces the AI signal.
Inversion patterns appear at the other end of the table. The Pittsburgh Steelers, valued 20th in the league, rank seventh in Citation Share. The Cincinnati Bengals, Jacksonville Jaguars, and Detroit Lions all show double-digit positive gaps between AI visibility and valuation — what the Index calls "real but invisible assets on the balance sheet."
The Dallas Cowboys dominate the Index. Citation Share Score: 100.0. The team is named first in 39% of every NFL-related AI query — a 295-out-of-750 first-place mention rate. The #2 franchise, the Kansas City Chiefs, scored 51.6 — a margin that holds across every engine and every prompt bucket the Index measured.
The Chiefs result is notable for a different reason. For the first time since 2014, Kansas City missed the playoffs in the 2025 season. The franchise still ranked second in AI visibility. The report calls this "the largest positive gap between performance and brand authority in the league" — a 21-position separation between Citation Share rank and on-field finish.
The most counter-intuitive finding may involve the reigning champion. The Seattle Seahawks won Super Bowl LX over New England on February 8, 2026, finished with the league's best regular-season record, and led the NFL in points allowed per game. They rank 12th in AI citations. "AI engines have not caught up to the championship," the Index notes.
"Sponsorship inventory is priced on attention," Torossian said in the report. "Attention now runs through ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini, and Google AI Overviews — not the broadcast and not the timeline. The Jets are the sixth-most-valuable franchise in football and twenty-eighth in citations. Some sponsor is paying full freight for a brand that AI engines barely return. Build the infrastructure before the renewal — not during it."
The Index will refresh quarterly. The next edition is scheduled for the NFL off-season window — pre-camp prompts, free-agency movement, draft impact. An in-season cut follows in Q4 2026. A playoff and free-agent special is scheduled for Q1 2027. The methodology will remain unchanged across refreshes to preserve trend integrity.
For NFL franchise communications departments — none of which currently measures AI citation share, according to the Index — the practical implication is direct. The signal is now measured. The mispricings are now visible. The next move is whether to build infrastructure inside the contract cycle, or pay for the gap when a sponsor renewal comes up.
The full Index, methodology, and franchise-by-franchise rankings are public.
Related coverage on Everything-PR:
- What Citation Share Means for the Modern Communications Function
- Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) — Glossary and Practitioner Notes
- How AI Search Is Reshaping Sponsorship Valuation
External references:
- The 5W NFL Citation Share Index 2026 · Full Report
- Downloadable CSV Dataset
- 5W Research Hub
- 5W GEO Practice
- Forbes 2025 NFL Franchise Valuations
Everything-PR editorial policy: Everything-PR shares an owner with 5W. The two operate as independent editorial and commercial entities. Everything-PR covers competitors, rivals, and category authorities freely and on the merits. Coverage of 5W is held to the same news threshold as coverage of any other firm.
