How was the study done?
The study models citation share across five systems, ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews, for approximately 75 consumer-intent prompts spanning six sub-categories. Those sub-categories are denominational identity, Christian media, faith-based nonprofits, theologians and pastors, sermon and devotional discovery, and reputation and trust.
Prompts use natural consumer language, such as "what is the largest Protestant denomination," "best Christian magazines," "most influential evangelical theologians" and "is the Southern Baptist Convention safe." They were not written to favor any institution.
Each institution received a score from 0 to 100 built from five equally weighted dimensions: how often it is named, whether the mentions are neutral, positive or controversial, whether the system cites the institution's own content or third-party coverage, whether it appears across all five systems, and what share of sub-category prompts return it. The scores are modeled from Claude's knowledge plus web search at a single point in time. EPR does not log query runs, so every figure in this report is a directional estimate and not a statistical claim.
What is the Faith Authority Stack?
The Faith Authority Stack is a six-tier model of where religious citation share comes from. Higher tiers anchor what the engines treat as canonical, and lower tiers shape tone, interpretation and reputation.
| Tier | Layer | Examples |
| 1 | Canonical texts | Bible translations, Talmud, Quran, Bhagavad Gita, Tripitaka, Vedas |
| 2 | Institutional authorities | Vatican, SBC, Lambeth, USCCB, Chief Rabbinate, Al-Azhar |
| 3 | Denominational publishers | Crossway, B&H, Eerdmans, Ignatius Press, Maggid |
| 4 | Religious journalism | Christianity Today, RNS, National Catholic Register, Tablet |
| 5 | Independent creators | Major podcasts, megachurch media, named theologian platforms |
| 6 | Community interpretation | Reddit, Quora, YouTube comments, Discord communities |
The pattern across the stack is consistent. Institutions that publish like newsrooms, with sourced, dated, structured and cross-referenced pages, hold their position. Institutions that publish like marketing departments lose it.
Which religious institutions are cited most?
The Catholic Church and the Vatican rank first with a score of 92, followed by Christianity Today at 81 and Wikipedia, as a host of religion content, at 80. The table shows the modeled top 25 across all sub-categories and all five systems.
| Rank | Entity | Category | Score | Systems |
| 1 | Catholic Church / The Vatican | Denomination | 92 | All 5 |
| 2 | Christianity Today | Media | 81 | All 5 |
| 3 | Wikipedia (as host) | Infrastructure | 80 | All 5 |
| 4 | Southern Baptist Convention | Denomination | 78 | All 5 |
| 5 | Religion News Service | Media | 77 | All 5 |
| 6 | C.S. Lewis | Individual | 76 | All 5 |
| 7 | World Vision | Nonprofit | 74 | All 5 |
| 8 | Tim Keller | Individual | 72 | All 5 |
| 9 | Samaritan's Purse | Nonprofit | 70 | All 5 |
| 10 | YouVersion / Bible App | Devotional | 69 | All 5 |
| 11 | Bishop Robert Barron / Word on Fire | Individual | 67 | All 5 |
| 12 | The Gospel Coalition | Media | 65 | 4 of 5 |
| 13 | Bible Gateway | Devotional | 64 | All 5 |
| 14 | LDS Church | Denomination | 63 | All 5 |
| 15 | Compassion International | Nonprofit | 62 | All 5 |
| 16 | N.T. Wright | Individual | 60 | All 5 |
| 17 | Catholic Relief Services | Nonprofit | 59 | All 5 |
| 18 | Hillsong | Denomination/Media | 58 | All 5 |
| 19 | Chabad.org | Infrastructure | 56 | All 5 |
| 20 | National Catholic Register | Media | 55 | 4 of 5 |
| 21 | Desiring God / John Piper | Media/Individual | 54 | All 5 |
| 22 | United Methodist Church | Denomination | 52 | All 5 |
| 23 | The Salvation Army | Nonprofit | 51 | All 5 |
| 24 | Convoy of Hope | Nonprofit | 49 | 4 of 5 |
| 25 | Episcopal Church | Denomination | 47 | All 5 |
Modeled, directional. May 2026.
Most mid-tier denominations (PCA, ELCA, LCMS, Anglican Church in North America) and most regional Christian publications are absent from the top 25, as are the large majority of faith-based nonprofits with under $50 million in revenue.
Which denominations are cited most?
The Catholic Church leads denominational citation share with a score of 92, the Southern Baptist Convention follows at 78, and the LDS Church is third at 63. Citation share falls steeply after the top fourteen.
| Rank | Denomination | Score | Notes |
| 1 | Catholic Church | 92 | Vatican primary sources dominant |
| 2 | Southern Baptist Convention | 78 | Recent abuse investigation drives volume |
| 3 | LDS Church | 63 | High structured-content output |
| 4 | Hillsong | 58 | Cross-category, denomination + media |
| 5 | United Methodist Church | 52 | Schism coverage amplifies retrieval |
| 6 | Episcopal Church | 47 | Strong cultural press coverage |
| 7 | Greek Orthodox / Eastern Orthodox | 44 | Wikipedia-heavy citation profile |
| 8 | Assemblies of God | 42 | Limited cross-engine consistency |
| 9 | Jehovah's Witnesses | 40 | Reddit-heavy reputation profile |
| 10 | Presbyterian Church (USA) | 38 | Structured archives outperform peers |
| 11 | Presbyterian Church in America | 32 | Theological depth, narrow retrieval |
| 12 | ELCA / Lutheran Church | 30 | Mid-tier digital infrastructure |
| 13 | LCMS / Missouri Synod | 28 | Confessional content well-indexed |
| 14 | Anglican Church in North America | 21 | Newer entity, building corpus |
Modeled, directional. May 2026.
The Catholic lead comes from publishing scale. The Vatican site, vatican.va, hosts encyclicals, papal addresses, doctrinal documents and historical archives in structured, dated, citable form across multiple languages. No other major religious body publishes primary sources at a scale and depth that the indexed web can fully absorb.
The Southern Baptist Convention's second-place score is partly driven by abuse investigation coverage rather than theology. Its retrieval profile is heavily shaped by the 2022 Guidepost Solutions report and the journalism that followed. Below the top fourteen, most American denominations with under one million members barely appear in AI answers to consumer-intent prompts.
Christianity Today leads Christian media citation share with a score of 81, ahead of Religion News Service at 77 and The Gospel Coalition at 65.
| Rank | Outlet | Score | Notes |
| 1 | Christianity Today | 81 | Reported features, deep archive |
| 2 | Religion News Service | 77 | Cross-tradition breaking news |
| 3 | The Gospel Coalition | 65 | Reformed authority, narrower surface |
| 4 | National Catholic Register | 55 | Strong Catholic vertical authority |
| 5 | Catholic News Agency | 53 | Wire-service citation density |
| 6 | Desiring God | 54 | Tied to John Piper individual authority |
| 7 | World Magazine | 48 | Conservative news lane |
| 8 | First Things | 46 | Academic-popular crossover |
| 9 | The Christian Century | 44 | Mainline Protestant authority |
| 10 | Word on Fire | 43 | Tied to Bishop Barron authority |
| 11 | Bible Gateway (editorial) | 41 | Devotional + reference hybrid |
| 12 | Crosswalk | 38 | High traffic, mid citation density |
| 13 | Relevant Magazine | 33 | Cultural reach, thin archive |
| 14 | Charisma | 30 | Pentecostal vertical, narrow retrieval |
| 15 | Got Questions | 28 | High volume, mid authority |
Modeled, directional. May 2026.
Christianity Today's position rests on three advantages: a sixty-year archive of reported journalism, a clear editorial standard, and deep coverage of theologians, pastors and movements. Mike Cosper's podcast on Mars Hill is among the most-cited single pieces of Christian journalism in answers about American evangelicalism, and that citation profile adds to the parent publication's.
Relevant Magazine shows the gap between audience and archive. It has historically had one of the largest social audiences in Christian media and one of the lower citation scores in this study. Its content favored cultural commentary over reported journalism, and the engines reward archive depth and editorial rigor. For the outlet-by-outlet breakdown, see Christian Media's AI Search Reckoning.
Which faith nonprofits are cited most?
World Vision leads faith nonprofit citation share with a score of 74, followed by Samaritan's Purse at 70 and Compassion International at 62.
| Rank | Organization | Score | Notes |
| 1 | World Vision | 74 | Largest faith-based aid org, deep press archive |
| 2 | Samaritan's Purse | 70 | Disaster relief dominant, Franklin Graham entity |
| 3 | Compassion International | 62 | Child sponsorship category leader |
| 4 | Catholic Relief Services | 59 | Catholic vertical authority |
| 5 | Salvation Army | 51 | Mainstream brand recognition |
| 6 | Convoy of Hope | 49 | Disaster relief, mid-tier press |
| 7 | World Renew | 41 | CRC-affiliated, structured reporting |
| 8 | Operation Blessing | 39 | CBN-affiliated, narrower retrieval |
| 9 | Cru (Campus Crusade) | 37 | Evangelism category authority |
| 10 | Young Life | 32 | Youth ministry, regional press depth |
| 11 | Food for the Hungry | 28 | Mid-tier digital footprint |
| 12 | International Justice Mission | 27 | Trafficking-specific authority |
| 13 | Habitat for Humanity (faith-rooted) | 26 | Cross-category positioning |
| 14 | American Bible Society | 24 | Heritage authority, modest retrieval |
Modeled, directional. May 2026.
The top eight organizations account for most of the citation share in faith-based philanthropy answers. Smaller organizations with strong programs and weak digital infrastructure appear least often. If donors keep turning to AI tools for research, those organizations are the most exposed.
Which theologians and pastors carry the most authority?
C.S. Lewis ranks first among individuals with a score of 76, ahead of Tim Keller at 72 and Bishop Robert Barron at 67.
| Rank | Individual | Score | Tradition |
| 1 | C.S. Lewis | 76 | Anglican / Apologetics |
| 2 | Tim Keller | 72 | Reformed / Evangelical |
| 3 | Bishop Robert Barron | 67 | Catholic |
| 4 | N.T. Wright | 60 | Anglican / NT scholarship |
| 5 | John Piper | 54 | Reformed Baptist |
| 6 | Billy Graham | 52 | Evangelical |
| 7 | Dietrich Bonhoeffer | 51 | Lutheran / Historic |
| 8 | Pope Francis | 50 | Catholic |
| 9 | Pope Benedict XVI / Joseph Ratzinger | 48 | Catholic |
| 10 | Rick Warren | 44 | Evangelical |
| 11 | R.C. Sproul | 42 | Reformed |
| 12 | Beth Moore | 40 | Evangelical / Cross-tradition |
| 13 | A.W. Tozer | 39 | Historic evangelical |
| 14 | John MacArthur | 38 | Fundamentalist evangelical |
| 15 | Rabbi Jonathan Sacks | 36 | Orthodox Judaism |
Modeled, directional. May 2026.
Lewis remains the most cited Christian thinker in the modeled results six decades after his death. His books are in print with every major publisher, taught in academic and seminary settings, cross-referenced by thousands of secondary authors, and well represented on Wikipedia and in academic databases.
Tim Keller died in May 2023, and his modeled citation share has risen since. In these results, a well-organized body of posthumous publishing can grow citation share and not only preserve it. Major Catholic theologians such as Hans Urs von Balthasar, Henri de Lubac and Karl Rahner, and Jewish thinkers such as Heschel, Soloveitchik and Wyschogrod, appear in academic retrieval but rarely in consumer-intent answers. That gap reflects audience size, not the weight of their authority.
YouVersion and its Bible App lead sermon and devotional discovery with a score of 69, followed by Bible Gateway at 64 and Bible Hub at 51.
| Rank | Platform | Score | Notes |
| 1 | YouVersion / Bible App | 69 | 700M+ installs, dominant Bible reference |
| 2 | Bible Gateway | 64 | Web-first, deep cross-reference |
| 3 | Bible Hub | 51 | Concordance + lexicon strength |
| 4 | Logos / Faithlife | 48 | Academic and pastoral depth |
| 5 | The Bible Project | 47 | Animation + structured theology |
| 6 | Our Daily Bread | 42 | Devotional category leader |
| 7 | Hallow (Catholic app) | 41 | Catholic devotional leader |
| 8 | Olive Tree | 38 | Mid-tier app, narrower retrieval |
| 9 | Jesus Calling (Sarah Young) | 38 | High consumer reach |
| 10 | Pray.com | 34 | Newer entrant, paid subscription |
Modeled, directional. May 2026.
YouVersion's scale gives it an advantage: when a user asks about a Bible passage, the answer is disproportionately likely to reflect YouVersion's translation availability and cross-reference structure. Sermon discovery is also moving from long Sunday services to 90-second clips. Churches that publish short-form video aggressively, including Elevation, Hillsong, Bethel and Transformation Church, hold visible positions among younger audiences. GEO for churches explains how churches can publish sermons and staff pages so that AI engines can find them.
How do AI answers handle reputation and trust questions?
AI answers to reputation questions lean on the most-reported controversies and on Wikipedia, and they weigh reported journalism above an institution's own response. Reputation queries produce different retrieval patterns from neutral questions about a tradition.
Catholic Church abuse archives, the SBC abuse investigation, Hillsong leadership scandals, the Mars Hill collapse, the Ravi Zacharias revelations and LDS historical doctrine controversies surfaced in nearly every relevant prompt across all five systems. When a system summarizes an institutional controversy, the underlying source structure is heavily shaped by Wikipedia, even when other sources are cited.
A report from Christianity Today, the New York Times or Religion News Service typically outweighs the institution's own statement in retrieval ranking. Reddit shapes tone more than facts: subreddits such as r/exchristian, r/exmormon, r/exjw and r/Catholicism influence how responses are framed even when they are not cited directly. Institutions that publish primary documentation, such as investigation reports, audit findings, governance changes and financial disclosures, tend to outperform those that publish only narrative statements.
How do Wikipedia, Reddit and fabricated answers shape religious results?
Wikipedia, Reddit and AI-generated errors each shape religious answers in a different way.
Wikipedia is among the most-cited single sources in the study. Its articles on denominations, megachurches, pastors and theologians are often written by critics, former members or journalists covering controversies, and the controversy section frequently outweighs the beliefs or history sections in length and link density. Institutions cannot edit Wikipedia about themselves and should not try. They can publish structured, sourced primary documents that Wikipedia editors are required to cite.
Reuters reported in February 2024 that Reddit agreed to license its content to Google, and religious subreddits are now part of the material AI systems draw on. Responses about religious institutions can take on Reddit's tone even without citing it, and ex-member communities carry more weight than active-member spaces.
Religion is also prone to a kind of error that appears less often in other fields. The study flags fabricated quotations attributed to real theologians, invented citations to documents that do not exist, attribution mix-ups between traditions, compressed Bible passages misquoted as direct scripture, and confident answers about denominations that do not exist or that blend similar names.
Why are mid-size faith institutions disappearing from AI answers?
Mid-size faith institutions rarely appear because the engines reward archive depth, citation density, structured content and outside references, and the top institutions have built all four over decades. This is the study's most significant strategic finding.
The pattern repeats in every sub-category. The top three to eight institutions capture most citation share, the next twenty to thirty capture small and shrinking shares, and everything below that threshold is largely absent. The mid-tier has invested in member services, local outreach and traditional press relations instead.
Digital infrastructure can outweigh size. A megachurch with 50,000 attendees and strong online publishing can outperform a denomination with two million members and weak online publishing, and a faith nonprofit with a $200 million budget and a real press function can outperform ten nonprofits with $20 million budgets and none. Mid-tier institutions face a choice over the next 24 months between investing in visibility and accepting a weaker position relative to larger peers.
How do the five AI systems differ?
The five systems return different results, so an institution's authority in AI answers is only as strong as its weakest system.
- ChatGPT is most likely to surface mainstream institutions and major journalistic sources, and it is strongest at synthesis across traditions.
- Claude is strongest on theological nuance and is more likely to flag differences among Reformed, Arminian, Lutheran and Catholic positions on contested questions.
- Gemini relies more heavily on Google-indexed sources, including institutional websites, and performs best for institutions with deep, well-structured sites.
- Perplexity is the most transparent about its sources, tends to name the specific publications behind an answer, and favors recent reporting.
- Google AI Overviews comes closest to traditional Google results and leans heavily on Wikipedia and institutional sites.
Top-tier institutions surface consistently in all five systems, while mid-tier institutions show wide variance from one system to the next.
What about religious search outside English?
This study covers English-language prompts only, and three patterns suggest the global picture differs.
Arabic-language Islamic retrieval spans several schools of jurisprudence, with Al-Azhar, Dar al-Iftaa and the Qom seminaries as institutional anchors. Hebrew-language Jewish retrieval splits across Hebrew, English, Yiddish and Russian publishing, and Chabad.org runs the most consistently multilingual Jewish institutional archive. In Spanish, Vatican publishing is consistent, while Evangelical media is fragmented across Latin American countries and U.S. Hispanic communities.
WhatsApp and YouTube mediate religious discovery in much of the global South in ways that web-based AI answers underrepresent. EPR will cover this in dedicated reporting.
How can faith institutions improve their citation share?
Faith institutions improve citation share by publishing like newsrooms: structured, sourced, dated and cross-referenced pages on the open web. The steps differ by tier of the Faith Authority Stack.
Institutional authorities should publish theological positions, polity documents and doctrinal statements as dated, citable web pages and not as PDFs or member-only portals. They should build pages for senior leaders with full credentials, dated education and ordination records and verifiable publications, and they should maintain a press function and apply schema markup across their sites.
Denominational publishers should index their backlists, build author pages with full bibliographies, and make book content excerptable instead of locking it behind purchase walls. Religious journalism outlets should invest in archive structure, tag every piece by topic, denomination, theologian, scripture reference and date, hire reporters and not only commentators, and publish primary documents such as court filings and investigation reports alongside narrative coverage.
Faith-based nonprofits should publish program data in structured form, post annual impact reports as proper web pages, and build pages for leadership, board and senior program staff. They should also address controversies directly, because buried controversies stay in the indexed record. Local churches should transcribe every sermon, turn "what we believe" into long-form explainers, build pages for pastoral staff, apply schema markup, and pitch local and religious press. GEO for churches and effective church marketing programs cover the details.
Where does EPR cover faith in more depth?
EPR covers faith across four sub-clusters, each with its own hub page. The table lists each hub and what it covers.
| Sub-cluster | Hub URL | What it covers |
| Catholic / Vatican | /pope-public-relations | Vatican communications under the Alvarado reform era, the most-cited religious institution in retrieval. Related coverage includes the clergy abuse crisis case study and the McVatican partnership case. |
| Muslim audiences | /british-muslims-public-relations | Marketing to Muslim consumers, Islamic institutional communications, faith-targeted advertising agencies, and the named crisis cases that shaped modern Muslim PR. |
| Jewish communications | /great-jewish-communicators | Jewish communicators across rabbinics, journalism, diplomacy, comedy, business and public thought, plus holiday brand marketing and Jewish media in AI search. Israel-focused coverage is in the Israel and AI visibility hub. |
| Christian media & church | /christian-medias-ai-search-reckoning | Christian media authority in the era of AI citation: Christianity Today, RNS, Gospel Coalition, EWTN and The Pillar. Church and megachurch communications, including Life.Church, Hillsong and Elevation, are in GEO for churches and effective church marketing programs. |
Cross-tradition coverage lives alongside these hubs, including faith-based nonprofits, faith-based PR firms and the Who Controls AI Answers: Religion entry.