- Fifteen of 30 solicitations scored price as a standalone criterion, with a median of 15% of base points and a range of 5% to 30%.
- Eight of those 15 weights were 15% or lower, and four were 25% or higher.
- Four of 30 kept price out of the first round: Illinois and Utah set technical thresholds, Quincy opened price after technical review, and New Haven excluded cost at qualification.
- Three of 30 attached points to an interview or presentation stage, which can shrink the price share after bids are scored.
- Seven solicitations named cost as a factor with no weight, three requested a budget or fee with no separate scored weight, two folded price into a broader factor, and one showed a cost line with an unverified maximum.
How did the 30 buyers treat price?
Fifteen of the 30 buyers scored price as a standalone criterion, and the other 15 used six different approaches. Twenty of the 30 published a weighted rubric, so five weighted rubrics still did not isolate a price share: Walton County, Monroe County, the California Film Commission, the New Mexico Administrative Office of the Courts and New Haven.
| Price treatment | Solicitations out of 30 |
| Standalone financial criterion | 15 |
| Cost considered without a stated weight | 7 |
| Cost embedded in a broader scored factor | 2 |
| Budget or fee requested without a separate scored weight verified | 3 |
| Price reviewed after technical ranking | 1 |
| Cost expressly excluded during qualification | 1 |
| Cost criterion shown but its maximum could not be verified | 1 |
A standalone financial criterion scores the financial proposal itself, including cost reasonableness or fee transparency where the buyer calls for it. A mixed criterion combines price with other considerations, such as overall feasibility or organizational financial ability, so the price share cannot be isolated.
Among the 30 rubrics, 20 were weighted, 7 listed criteria without weights, 2 named scoring without publishing usable maximums (Sebastopol, California, and Mount Holly, New Jersey) and 1 used an ordinal rating scale (Quincy, Massachusetts).
How much weight does price get in a PR RFP?
Price carried a median of 15% of base points across the 15 solicitations with a standalone weight, with a low of 5% at Atlanta Housing and Farragut, Tennessee, and a high of 30% at the California Surgeon General and Basalt, Colorado. The mean was 16.6%, close to the median, so no single outlier distorts the picture.
Standalone price weights in 15 public PR solicitations, lowest to highest. Source: buyer-issued solicitations, reviewed by Everything-PR, 2025 to 2026.
| Buyer | Scope group | Price points of base points | Price share |
| Town of Farragut, TN | Tourism | 5 of 100 | 5% |
| Atlanta Housing, GA | General communications | 5 of 100 | 5% |
| Grand County / Moab Office of Tourism, UT | Tourism | 10 of 100 | 10% |
| East Bay Regional Park District, CA | General communications | 10 of 100 | 10% |
| First 5 San Mateo County, CA | Public information | 10 of 100 | 10% |
| Hawai‘i Agribusiness Development Corporation, HI | General communications | 15 of 125 | 12% |
| Hawai‘i Tourism Authority, HI | General communications | 15 of 100 | 15% |
| MetroPlusHealth / NYC Health + Hospitals, NY | Public information | 15 of 100 | 15% |
| Illinois Office of Tourism, IL | Tourism | 84 of 504 | 16.67% |
| Central Basin Municipal Water District, CA | General communications | 20 of 100 | 20% |
| Oregon Tourism Commission / Travel Oregon, OR | Tourism | 200 of 1,000 | 20% |
| Florida Department of Management Services, FL | General communications | 100 of 400 | 25% |
| Utah Division of Purchasing / Risk Management, UT | Public information | 250 of 1,000 | 25% |
| Office of the California Surgeon General, CA | Public information | 300 of 1,000 | 30% |
| Town of Basalt, CO | General communications | 30 of 100 | 30% |
Grouped into bands, five weights fell between 5% and 10%, four between 12% and 17%, four between 20% and 25%, and two at 30%. Everything-PR's government PR bid playbook offers an illustrative 15 to 20 points for price. In this audit, five of the 15 weights fell between 15% and 20%, eight were 15% or lower, and six were 20% or higher.
Atlanta Housing shows the low end. Its written rubric gave cost 5 of 100 points, gave 30 points each to professional competence, staffing and qualifications, and firm experience, and gave 5 points to ethical behavior. Central Basin Municipal Water District in California shows the middle: qualifications and experience 50%, work approach 30% and fee proposal 20%. Basalt shows the high end, with team experience 35, strategy 35 and fee proposal 30.
Standalone price share by scope group. Source: Everything-PR scorecard of 30 solicitations. Groups are small, so differences are directional only.
| Scope group | Solicitations with a standalone weight | Median price share | Range |
| Tourism | 4 | 13.3% | 5% to 20% |
| General communications | 7 | 15% | 5% to 30% |
| Public information | 4 | 20% | 10% to 30% |
Public information buyers, such as the California Surgeon General and MetroPlusHealth, gave price the highest median at 20%. Tourism buyers gave it the lowest at 13.3%. With four to seven records per group, the audit treats that gap as a lead for further study, not a finding.
What do buyers mean by price in a scored rubric?
Several buyers scored price as a judgment of reasonableness and value, not as a lowest-bid formula. Hawai‘i Tourism Authority assigned 15 of 100 points to price, with 7 tied to the price calculation and 8 to price reasonableness and realism. Hawai‘i Agribusiness Development Corporation assigned 15 of 125 points, split into 10 for competitiveness and 5 for reasonableness, which is 12% of its base score.
Basalt's 30-point fee criterion evaluated a cost matrix, rate reasonableness, fee transparency and cost efficiency. East Bay Regional Park District in California scored a 10-point cost and value criterion that looked at the financial proposal and budget use.
Two buyers mixed price with other judgments. Walton County, Florida, placed a 10-point return on investment item, which considered fees alongside overall value and feasibility, inside a 35-point block. Monroe County, Florida, collected a fee and hourly rate card under a 20-point financial ability factor that covered other measures. The audit did not assign either buyer a price percentage.
How do interviews change the price share?
An optional interview that carries its own points enlarges the score denominator, so the same price points become a smaller share of the final total. The price share after an interview equals price points divided by base points plus interview points.
The Office of the California Surgeon General published the clearest example. It assigned 300 of 1,000 base points to year-one cost, a 30% weight. An optional interview added up to 200 points, so the same 300 points became 25% of a 1,200-point total.
First 5 San Mateo County gave cost 10 of 100 points in Phase 1 and printed a separate 100-point rubric for an optional Phase 2 interview. The reviewed scoring sections did not say how the two phases combine, so the audit does not infer a final price share.
Atlanta Housing took a third approach. It published a preliminary rubric and allowed the committee to add or deduct points after a presentation or interview. East Bay Regional Park District, Lake County and Five Corners mentioned optional interviews without showing separate points, and the audit did not change their coding.
Which buyers judge quality before price?
Four of the 30 buyers kept price out of the first round of evaluation, and two of them set the same 70% bar. Illinois Office of Tourism required 294 of 420 nonprice points before price opened, which is 70%. Utah Division of Purchasing required a technical gate of 525 of 750 points, also 70%, before cost was evaluated.
The other two used different mechanics. Quincy, Massachusetts, rated technical criteria on an ordinal 0 to 3 scale and opened price proposals only after the technical review. New Haven, Connecticut, excluded cost at the qualification stage and negotiated price separately, with 40 points for work samples, 40 for similar public-sector experience and 20 for organizational capacity.
Illinois and Utah still assigned price a numeric share, 84 of 504 points (16.67%) and 250 of 1,000 points (25%). Those points only affect bidders that clear the gate, so a proposal below the technical threshold never reaches the price score.
How can bidders and buyers use these findings?
Bidders can use the audit to check a rubric the same way for every solicitation, and buyers can use it to see which scoring details bidders look for. Five checks cover most of the variation in the 30 records.
- Find the maximum points for price and divide by the base maximum to get the price share.
- Check whether a technical threshold must be cleared before price is scored, and note the cutoff.
- Read the definition of price, because reasonableness, realism and fee transparency can carry part of the points.
- Check whether an interview or presentation carries points, then recompute the price share with the interview points added to the denominator.
- Confirm the latest addendum, since several records in this sample were revised after the original posting.
Buyers writing their own bids can publish each criterion's maximum points and state how any interview affects the final score. Seven of the 30 solicitations named cost without a weight, and three asked for a fee with no scored weight, so bidders in those cases had no published way to compare price against quality. Everything-PR's PR agency RFP template includes a scoring table for that purpose.
Agencies preparing responses can pair this audit with how to win a PR agency RFP and the PR firm cost guide. For award-side evidence on what public buyers actually approved, see the public PR contract audit.
What are the 30 solicitations in the audit?
The 30 solicitations run from a March 2025 posting to a November 2026 issue, and each row links to the buyer-issued document. The price column shows the standalone weight where one could be verified and the buyer's own treatment where it could not.
The 30 public PR solicitations reviewed, in order of document date. Source: buyer-issued solicitations and supporting records linked in each row.
| Buyer | Solicitation | Published scoring format | Price treatment or base weight | Evidence |
| Illinois Office of Tourism, IL | 25-420DCEO-TOURI-B-46748 | Weighted | 16.67% | Solicitation file |
| Grand County / Moab Office of Tourism, UT | Moab tourism PR | Weighted | 10% | Solicitation file |
| Lake County, CA | 251120 | Unweighted | Cost considered, weight unstated | Solicitation file |
| Commerce City, CO | RFP-ED-25-007 | Unweighted | Cost considered, weight unstated | Solicitation file |
| Walton County Tourism Department, FL | 25-17 | Weighted | Cost embedded in a broader factor | Solicitation file |
| Central Basin Municipal Water District, CA | 215 | Weighted | 20% | Solicitation file |
| East Bay Regional Park District, CA | Public relations support | Weighted | 10% | Solicitation file |
| Town of Farragut, TN | 2026-12 | Weighted | 5% | Solicitation file |
| City of Quincy, MA | Consulting Services for Public Relations | Ordinal | Price reviewed after technical ranking | Solicitation file |
| Hawai‘i Tourism Authority, HI | 26-06 / P26000550 | Weighted | 15% | Solicitation file · Supporting record |
| Florida Department of Management Services, FL | 25-82101800-RFP / RFP-13950 | Weighted | 25% | Solicitation file · Supporting record |
| Atlanta Housing, GA | 2026-0016 | Weighted | 5% | Solicitation file |
| Monroe County / Visit Florida Keys, FL | Professional International Public Relations Services FY 2026 | Weighted | Cost embedded in a broader factor | Solicitation file · Supporting record |
| California Film Commission / GO-Biz, CA | 0000037220 | Weighted | Cost line present, maximum unverified | Solicitation file |
| City of Calabasas, CA | Communications Services | Unweighted | Cost considered, weight unstated | Solicitation file |
| Office of the California Surgeon General, CA | 2025-591-OSG | Weighted | 30% | Solicitation file |
| City of Aransas Pass, TX | 2025-004 | Unweighted | Budget or fee requested; no distinct scored weight verified | Solicitation file |
| Town of West New York, NJ | Public Relations Services for 2026, third solicitation | Unweighted | Cost considered, weight unstated | Solicitation file |
| Township of North Bergen, NJ | 2026-8 | Unweighted | Cost considered, weight unstated | Solicitation file |
| Five Corners Improvement District, TX | Marketing and Public Relations Services | Unweighted | Cost considered, weight unstated | Solicitation file |
| Hawai‘i Agribusiness Development Corporation, HI | 25-200-027 / P26001999 | Weighted | 12% | Solicitation file · Supporting record |
| City of Sebastopol, CA | Community Outreach | No maxima | Budget or fee requested; no distinct scored weight verified | Solicitation file |
| New Mexico Administrative Office of the Courts / JPEC, NM | 2026-AOC-007 | Weighted | Budget or fee requested; no distinct scored weight verified | Solicitation file |
| Township of Mount Holly, NJ | Public Relations Consultant | No maxima | Cost considered, weight unstated | Solicitation file |
| First 5 San Mateo County, CA | Communications Consultation Services | Weighted | 10% | Solicitation file |
| City of New Haven, CT | 2026-RFQ-CNH-379 | Weighted | Cost expressly excluded at qualification | Solicitation file |
| MetroPlusHealth / NYC Health + Hospitals, NY | MHP-1123 | Weighted | 15% | Solicitation file |
| Utah Division of Purchasing / Risk Management, UT | KK27-101 | Weighted | 25% | Solicitation file |
| Town of Basalt, CO | Public Communications Services | Weighted | 30% | Solicitation file · Supporting record |
| Oregon Tourism Commission / Travel Oregon, OR | 1149-1126RFP / S-976000-00018360 | Weighted | 20% | Solicitation file · Supporting record |
How was the PR RFP scoring audit conducted?
Everything-PR searched publicly accessible U.S. state and local procurement records for competitive RFPs, RFQs and equivalent qualifications solicitations in 2025 and 2026, through November 19, 2026. A procurement qualified if PR, earned media, public information or external strategic communications was a material part of the scope and the buyer-issued solicitation or scoring attachment was accessible.
The sample holds 26 RFPs, 3 RFQs and 1 request for statements of qualifications. The unit is one solicitation, and the audit kept the latest available revision where one could be identified. For statewide multi-category purchasing where the buyer applied one rubric by category, the PR category counted once. Some government documents were available only through public mirrors.
Document dates were coded by type: 21 issue dates, 5 deadlines, 3 posting dates and 1 posting month. For the five deadline records, the deadline identifies the dated procurement because the exact issue date could not be verified.
To classify pricing, the audit checked the scoring section and whether a requested budget or fee also received points. The procurement label, such as RFP or RFQ, did not determine coding. The price comparison divides the stated financial maximum by the stated base numerical maximum. It excludes mixed criteria, preference adjustments outside the base maximum, and standalone maximums that could not be verified. Where interviews were optional or scored separately, it uses the published written or base rubric.
Search passes used in the audit. Source: Everything-PR methodology record.
| Pass | Search examples and sources |
| Scope and title searches | Public relations services request for proposals 2025 or 2026; municipal communications consultant solicitation; tourism media relations procurement. Searched agency sites, city document centers and state procurement archives. |
| Rubric and attachment searches | Evaluation criteria points for PR proposals; strategic communications selection criteria; buyer name and solicitation number plus scoring, revision or addendum. Checked HIePRO, OregonBuys, city and county bid records, and public copies from OpenGov, BidNet and GovTribe. |
Which solicitations were excluded, and why?
What does the audit not show?
The audit shows scoring rules that were available to bidders, and it does not show award decisions, actual panel scores or whether price changed who won. A numeric base weight describes how a buyer framed the evaluation before interviews, thresholds and preferences, and final rankings can follow other rules.
The sample is a purposive discovery sample. Searches that included scoring terms favor documents that expose their rubrics, so the finding that 15 of 30 published a standalone price weight describes the reviewed records and is not a national rate. Oregon's solicitation was still open when reviewed, and later scoring amendments there and at several other buyers were not verified.
Readers who want the pricing side of public PR work can compare these rules with the public PR contract audit and browse open assignments in the government PR RFP directory or the wider PR and marketing RFP hub.