In an Everything-PR audit of 40 FDA-posted U.S. human-food recall notices first posted August 19 through October 29, 2026, 0 of 40 (0%) put the product and brand, a usable product identifier and an explicit customer instruction together in the headline and first two substantive paragraphs. Across the full notice, 37 of 40 (92.5%) supplied all three.
Original research by EPR Research. Last updated November 19, 2026.
- 36 of 40 notices (90%) named the product and brand in the opening, 7 of 40 (17.5%) gave a usable identifier, and 2 of 40 (5%) gave a customer instruction.
- Every notice but one carried a usable identifier somewhere on the page (39 of 40, 97.5%), so the facts were published.
- Two notices, WinCo's salsa bean dip and Kofinas olive oil, gave no instruction to a customer who still had the product.
In This Study
Can customers tell if their product was recalled?
Most full notices included the information needed to match the product and find the next step, because 37 of 40 notices (92.5%) supplied the product and brand, a usable identifier and an explicit customer instruction somewhere on the page. The opening is where the gap sits: none of the 40 notices put all three in the headline and first two substantive paragraphs.
A recall notice has two jobs for the person holding the package. It has to say how to tell whether that package is affected, and it has to say what to do with it if it is. The name was usually easy to find, since 36 of 40 notices (90%) identified the product and brand in the opening, and all 40 did so on the full page. A lot number, date code or other way to tell affected stock from unaffected stock appeared in the opening of 7 of 40 notices (17.5%). A customer instruction appeared there in 2 of 40 (5%).
Both notices that opened with an instruction placed the detail a customer needed to match the product farther down the page. That is the pattern the audit set out to measure, and it is a pattern a communications team can change without gathering any new facts. For the crisis-communications background on food recalls, see EPR's food crisis communications guide.
What did the 40 notices tell customers, and where?
Product and brand appeared in the opening most often. Explicit customer instructions appeared there least often. The table shows each detail in the opening, anywhere on the notice, and only after the opening.
| Information | In the opening | Anywhere on the notice | Only after the opening |
| Product and brand | 36/40 (90%) | 40/40 (100%) | 4/40 (10%) |
| Usable product identifier | 7/40 (17.5%) | 39/40 (97.5%) | 32/40 (80%) |
| Distribution geography | 22/40 (55%) | 38/40 (95%) | 16/40 (40%) |
| Explicit customer instruction | 2/40 (5%) | 38/40 (95%) | 36/40 (90%) |
| Product and brand, identifier and instruction together | 0/40 (0%) | 37/40 (92.5%) | 37/40 (92.5%) |
| All four text criteria | 0/40 (0%) | 35/40 (87.5%) | 35/40 (87.5%) |
A label photo or other product visual was present on 37 of 40 notices (92.5%). The three without one were the Saint Francis Apizza, Mezzetta and Donutful notices. A product image counted even when it did not show a lot number, but the text scores required the identifying information to appear as text on the notice, where a search engine and a screen reader can find it.
Which notices put the identifying details first?
Seven of the 40 notices put a usable identifier in the opening: a lot, a date or date range, or a scope rule that separates affected packages from unaffected ones. The Lidl US notice for Gelatelli coffee and vanilla gelato, posted October 17, 2026, is the clearest, with the product, UPC, lot 085261 and a March 26, 2028 best-by date in the first paragraph and the affected markets in the second.
| Company and product | Identifier in the opening | Where |
| Lidl US, Gelatelli coffee and vanilla gelato | UPC, lot 085261 and March 26, 2028 best-by | Paragraph 1 |
| Eden Brothers, Calabrese broccoli seeds | Lots 1022067 and 1022068 | Paragraph 1 |
| Danone USA, So Delicious Dairy Free Salted Caramel Cluster pints | Best-by on or before April 3, 2028 | Paragraph 1 |
| Sierra Nevada Cheese Company, Graziers raw milk cheeses | All Graziers raw milk cheese currently on the market | Paragraph 1 |
| WinCo Foods, Hoagie Rolls | UPC 2-70552-00649-2 and best-by range of Sept. 10 to Nov. 3, 2026 | Paragraph 2 |
| WinCo Foods, Salsa Bean Dip | Best-if-used-by range of Aug. 14 to Sept. 25 | Second substantive paragraph |
| Kofinas, Garlic Mediterranean Infused Extra Virgin Olive Oil | Sales window of Aug. 31, 2025 to Aug. 27, 2026 | Paragraph 2 |
The Kofinas notice gave a sales window and no narrower code, so its identifier is the broadest of the seven. In 32 notices the lot, UPC or date that told a customer which package to set aside appeared only after the opening, often in a table below the text, and the original Made Fresh Salads text had no usable identifier for its cream cheese. The Lidl notice on the FDA site shows that a lot and a best-by date fit comfortably in one opening sentence.
Which notices put the customer instruction first?
Two of the 40 notices put a customer instruction in the opening: Haifa Smoked Fish, in its October 27, 2026 notice for cold-smoked sprats, and Wakefern Food Corp., in its September 22, 2026 notice for Wholesome Pantry organic unsweetened apple sauce. Haifa warned in the first paragraph against using the product even if it appears sound, and Wakefern said in the second paragraph that the product should not be consumed.
Both notices then pushed the matching detail down. Wakefern's third paragraph gave the 23 oz UPC and the June 16, 2027 best-by date that distinguish the affected stock. Haifa's full notice later specified that all lots of the cold-smoked sprats were included. The Wakefern notice and the Haifa notice supply the instruction, and the Lidl notice supplies the identifiers. Combined, they would make a complete opening.
An explicit customer instruction appeared only after the opening in 36 of 40 notices (90%). Two of 40 (5%) gave no explicit instruction anywhere on the page.
Did any notice leave out the customer instruction?
Two of the 40 notices gave no instruction to a customer who still had the product: WinCo Foods' salsa bean dip notice and the Kofinas olive oil notice. That is why the full-page instruction count is 38 of 40 (95%) and not 40 of 40.
The WinCo salsa bean dip notice described the affected trays, their date range and distribution. It explained that potentially affected merchandise had been removed from stores and listed ways to ask questions. It did not say what a customer who still had a tray should do.
The Kofinas notice described symptoms to watch for, offered a conditional refund to customers who reported reactions and listed a question line, all after the opening. It did not tell a customer holding a bottle whether to keep, discard or return it.
How can a correction change what a notice covers?
A correction can change what a date range covers, as the Made Fresh Salads recall shows. The first notice, posted September 6, 2026, named both deli salads and cream cheese, then gave expiration dates in a sentence that referred only to salads.
The corrected FDA page explicitly applied those dates to cream cheese too. EPR scored the original FDA notice as syndicated, with the FDA email bulletin as a supporting source, and checked it against the corrected FDA page. Using the corrected page would raise the opening identifier count from 7 of 40 (17.5%) to 8 of 40 (20%). The opening result for identification and action together would remain 0 of 40 (0%).
The lesson for recall teams is practical. When a correction changes which products or dates are covered, the revised matching rule belongs near the top of the page with the revision date, so a customer who read the first version sees the change.
How did EPR select and score the 40 notices?
EPR screened 124 FDA archive entries dated July 1 through October 31, 2026. Screening removed 46 out-of-scope entries and consolidated nine translations, expansions or same-event entries. EPR ranked the 69 eligible recall events by first FDA posting date, newest first, breaking same-day ties by canonical FDA URL in ascending order. The first 40 were scored. EPR recovered earlier versions for four revised notices.
EPR Research read the headline and first two substantive paragraphs of each company announcement, then scored the full FDA notice, including its product tables and summary fields. The audit used the FDA recall archive as its source.
- Screen the 124 archive rows and remove 46 out-of-scope rows, such as supplements, pet products and advisories without a recall.
- Consolidate nine translations, expansions or same-event entries.
- Rank the 69 remaining human-food recall events by first FDA posting date, newest first, using the canonical FDA URL to break same-day ties.
- Take the first 40 and score each on four text criteria, plus a separate check for a product visual.
- Recover earlier syndicated FDA text for four known revisions (Family Farmstead Dairy, Mezzetta, Made Fresh Salads and Momchipz) and record both the original source and the current FDA page.
How each detail was scored
A code had to identify the affected scope. For multiple lots, a complete list or usable range qualified. A clearly stated all-lots recall qualified without a code. Nationwide counted as geography, while a chain name or website alone did not. A direction to stop use, discard, return or contact the firm for a remedy qualified as an instruction. A warning that described the risk alone did not.
EPR's earlier food crisis communications analysis covered notice specificity and broader crisis response, and EPR's pet food recall tracker covers animal-food notices, which this audit left out. This study measures the placement of four defined details in individual human-food notices. Its figures describe the versions reviewed. The audit did not test comprehension, compliance or recall effectiveness, and the sample was drawn from FDA-posted notices, so it is not an estimate for all U.S. food recalls. More studies from the team are on the EPR Research hub.
What belongs in a food recall notice checklist?
A food recall notice checklist has three parts: the headline, the first two paragraphs and the page itself. Each part answers one question a customer has while holding the package. The checklist below is built from the placement gaps in the 40 notices, and it fits the crisis steps in EPR's crisis communications hub.
Headline
- Name the recall, the brand as sold and the exact product.
First two paragraphs
- Give the affected lot numbers, date codes or a clear all-lots rule. Say where to find the mark.
- State the affected stores or markets. Use "nationwide" only if that is the verified distribution.
- Tell customers with a matching product what to do now. Specify the return, disposal or replacement process and the contact for help.
- State the reason plainly.
On the page
- Match each variant to its codes, dates and sizes in a searchable table. Include a clear package image and a close-up of the mark.
- Open the published page on a phone. Check that the matching rule and customer action are visible in the opening and agree with the table.
- Date each revision. Put changes to affected products, markets or instructions near the top, and carry them through retailer and customer messages.
In 37 of the 40 notices, the product, the code and the instruction were already on the page. A recall team can apply this checklist by moving those three details into the headline and first two paragraphs and leaving the rest of the notice as written.