Purina's Beneful brand faced consumer backlash after online complaints in 2014 and a 2015 lawsuit alleging its dog food sickened and killed dogs, with propylene glycol as a focal ingredient. Nestlé Purina called the claims baseless. A Canadian class action was dismissed and a California federal judge ruled the Lucido class action failed to prove the product was unsafe, but the allegations still shaped how owners talked about the brand.
Corrected October 2026: the Lucido lawsuit was filed in early 2015, not February 2014 as an earlier version stated. Part of Everything-PR's pet industry coverage, at everything-pr.com/pets.
What ignited the Beneful controversy?
The controversy ignited in early 2015, when Frank Lucido filed a proposed class action against Purina. According to Petfood Industry, Lucido claimed Beneful injured his three dogs and that one of them died. Veterinary Practice News reported that the suit sought at least $5 million in damages for Lucido and other class plaintiffs on grounds of negligence, false advertising and other claims.
The lawsuit pointed to propylene glycol, an ingredient also used in some antifreeze formulations. That ingredient became a focal point for many pet owners.
Why did the antifreeze comparison confuse the underlying science?
The antifreeze comparison confused the underlying science because propylene glycol and ethylene glycol are chemically distinct compounds that consumers routinely mix up. Ethylene glycol is the toxic compound used in automotive antifreeze. Propylene glycol is a different, food grade polyol that the FDA classifies as generally recognized as safe for use in food.
The FDA's own regulatory history shows the specific risk sits with cats. In a final rule effective June 3, 1996, the agency excluded propylene glycol from cat food after studies linked the ingredient to Heinz body anemia in cats fed high concentrations. Propylene glycol remains permitted in dog food. That distinction rarely surfaced in the Beneful coverage, because a restricted-for-cats ingredient that shares a name with antifreeze is a harder story to tell accurately than the viral version.
How did Purina respond to the allegations?
Purina responded by calling the lawsuit baseless and the complaints social media-driven misinformation. Its statement, reported by Veterinary Practice News, said Beneful is "occasionally the subject of social media-driven misinformation" and that two earlier class actions with similar allegations had been dismissed.
In a statement reported by Global News, Purina said propylene glycol is a safe food additive and that Beneful is made with food-grade levels or above. Truth About Pet Food reported that Purina later removed propylene glycol from the Beneful line, and EPR has not independently confirmed the date or the reason.
How did the Beneful lawsuits end?
The Canadian class action, launched by Colleen Gendron in March 2015, was dismissed. Her lawyers told the Ontario Superior Court of Justice they could not prove that Beneful caused the injury or death of the plaintiff's pets, according to Global News. The suit had been proposed after 66 individuals were referred to a Canadian law firm.
In the United States, Petfood Industry reported that a California federal judge ruled the proposed Lucido class action failed to prove the product was unsafe.
How does Beneful compare to Purina's fight with Blue Buffalo?
Purina sat on both sides of an ingredient dispute in the same period. In May 2014 Purina sued Blue Buffalo for false advertising after testing found poultry by-product meal in some Blue Buffalo products. On 6 May 2015 Blue Buffalo acknowledged in court that a substantial and material portion of its food contained poultry by-product meal, and it agreed to pay $32 million to settle consumer class actions without admitting wrongdoing. Purina and Blue Buffalo settled their own lawsuits in November 2016, per Petfood Industry. EPR covers the Blue Buffalo side in When Pet PR Goes Wrong.
What should a pet food brand do differently today?
A pet food brand facing a similar scare should publish the specific, checkable facts in the first news cycle instead of leading with a blanket denial. Naming the regulatory status of a contested ingredient, including any species-specific restrictions, gives journalists and owners something concrete to verify. This is EPR's analysis.
A brand should also connect any later formula change to the public concern in plain words. Without that, a genuine improvement reads as a quiet confirmation of what the brand never acknowledged.
More Pet Industry Coverage
Section hub: Pets and the Pet Industry on Everything-PR. Category reference: The $158B Pet Industry: 2026 Trade Guide.