"Yes, Virginia, there is a Santa Claus" is the best-known line of a New York Sun editorial titled "Is There a Santa Claus?", published on September 21, 1897 in reply to a letter from eight-year-old Virginia O'Hanlon. Francis P. Church wrote it anonymously, and it is cited as the most reprinted newspaper editorial in the English language. It is also a model of how to answer a hard question directly.
The case matters to communicators because the answer came first, the reasoning came second, and the audience carried it forward for more than a century. A team that answers a hard question in its opening line gets quoted. A team that explains first gets paraphrased.
What happened in 1897?
In the fall of 1897, Virginia O'Hanlon, then eight years old, argued with her friends over whether Santa Claus was real, according to UPI's archive of the story. Her father advised her to write to the New York Sun to find out the truth, and her letter said her father told her that whatever appeared in the Sun was so.
The letter reached Francis P. Church, a senior Sun editorial writer who had been a Civil War correspondent, according to Fordham University. His reply ran on the editorial page on September 21, 1897. The Sun published it without a byline, and Church's authorship was not disclosed until after his death in 1906.
Why did the editorial work as communication?
The editorial worked because it answered the child's actual question in its first sentence and then gave a reason that held up for adults as well. Church opened by telling Virginia that her friends were wrong, then argued that the most real things in the world are often the ones nobody can see.
Why it works: A direct opening answer lets a reader take the conclusion even if they stop after one line, and the reasoning that follows rewards the readers who continue. This is the same answer-first structure that search engines and AI assistants extract from pages today, which is why the editorial still reads as quotable on its own.
The letter itself shows what the Sun's name was worth. Virginia wrote that her father told her to trust what the Sun printed, as The Examiner's reprint of the letter records. The asset behind the answer was the masthead's credibility, and Church spent it on a child's question instead of a news story.
How did one editorial become an annual event?
One editorial became an annual event because the Sun republished it on a schedule and readers kept reprinting it. The Sun printed it every Christmas season from 1924 until the paper ceased publication in 1950, according to the cultural history site Culture Now, and the editorial has since been translated into about 20 languages and adapted as a film, television specials, a musical and a cantata.
Virginia kept telling the story herself. Fordham University records that she earned her doctorate there in 1930, taught in the New York City school system, spoke with WNYC in 1937 about her letter, and appeared on The Perry Como Show.
Why it works: A fixed annual date turned a one-time piece into a ritual. The second life of the editorial came from repetition, not from new content.
What can PR teams learn from Yes, Virginia?
PR teams can take four lessons from the editorial, each tied to a documented choice.
- Answer in the first sentence. Church told Virginia her friends were wrong before he explained anything. Put your answer in the opening line of every statement, FAQ and press release.
- Answer the question that was asked. A child asked whether Santa was real, and the editorial answered that question. Check each draft against the exact question your audience asked.
- Spend credibility on the audience's question. The Sun used its authority to reassure a reader. Decide which of your public answers deserve your most trusted voice.
- Publish evergreen answers on a schedule. The Sun's annual reprint built a tradition. Choose a date, a page and a format for answers that stay true year after year.
For related reading, see EPR's guide to media relations, the Q4 holiday marketing calendar and the Holiday Shopping AI Recommendation Tracker.