Updated: November 2026
Corporate apologies work when they name the specific failure and pair it with action. Domino's admitted its pizza was bad and posted a 14.3% same-store sales gain in the first quarter of 2010, per Columbia Business School. KFC's "FCK" ad apologized for a 2018 UK chicken shortage, and JetBlue put the cost of its 2007 meltdown compensation at about $30 million. Five cases follow, including Peloton, which defended its ad.
Contents
- How did Domino's turn admitting its pizza was bad into a growth campaign?
- How did KFC's "FCK" ad turn a supply failure into a goodwill moment?
- How did Peloton respond to its 2019 holiday ad backlash?
- How did Johnson & Johnson handle the 1982 Tylenol crisis?
- How did JetBlue apologize after its 2007 meltdown?
- How do the five cases compare?
- What is the timeline of these apologies?
- Why does the apology format matter more than the apology itself?
- What should an apology checklist include?
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
How did Domino's turn admitting its pizza was bad into a growth campaign?
Domino's launched its "Pizza Turnaround" campaign on December 27, 2009 in the United States, pairing an on-camera admission with a reformulated recipe, and reported a 14.3% rise in domestic same-store sales in the first quarter of 2010. The campaign, from agency Crispin Porter + Bogusky, is recorded in the WARC Cannes case entry, which calls it the largest quarterly sales increase in fast food history.
The campaign showed leadership acknowledging criticism from test groups of the old pizza, as the AOL Daily Finance report described, and it ran as the company reformulated its recipe. Then-president Patrick Doyle told Nation's Restaurant News that the new pizza accounted for all of the 14.3% gain. PMQ reports Doyle called the result historic.
The gain lasted beyond a single quarter. Columbia Business School reports that third-quarter 2010 same-store sales were up 11.2% over the same period of 2009, and the NACS summary of a Financial Times report says domestic same-store sales rose 12.9% over two years, against 5.7% for Papa John's and 2% for Pizza Hut.
Why it works: In EPR's reading, quoting real criticism signals honesty a polished ad cannot fake, and pairing the admission with a genuine product change gives the audience a reason to believe it. See also EPR's Domino's turnaround analysis.
How did KFC's "FCK" ad turn a supply failure into a goodwill moment?
KFC ran a full-page apology on February 23, 2018 in The Sun and Metro, showing an empty bucket with its logo letters rearranged to read "FCK," after a chicken shortage closed hundreds of UK restaurants. CNBC reported the ad, and It's Nice That credits agency Mother London.
The shortage followed a change of delivery partner: Marketing Week reports the ad apologized for closures after problems at new supplier DHL, and Yahoo News reports the shortage forced the chain to close more than half of its 900 British restaurants. The ad also directed readers to a microsite with more information, per It's Nice That. The agency's One Show entry says the two newspapers have a combined audience of just over 6 million and that 733 articles have since carried the image.
Why it works: In EPR's reading, a crisis caused by an undeniable failure, no chicken at a chicken restaurant, cannot be spun, so naming it with humor disarmed the criticism. EPR covers the case in depth in its KFC FCK apology ad analysis.
How did Peloton respond to its 2019 holiday ad backlash?
Peloton defended its holiday commercial rather than apologizing: the company said it was disappointed that some viewers misinterpreted the ad, which drew accusations of sexism after its December 2019 airing. HuffPost via Yahoo reported the stock dropped almost 10% following the backlash, while BuzzFeed News, citing the Wall Street Journal, put the fall at 15% and $1.5 billion in market value that week.
The company's statement to ABC News said the holiday spot was created to celebrate a fitness and wellness journey, per Good Morning America, and The Fly reported that Peloton stood firmly behind the commercial and did not link its stock movement to the response. The backlash then became a joke: on December 7, 2019 Ryan Reynolds' Aviation Gin released a spoof starring the same actress, Monica Ruiz, titled "The Gift That Doesn't Give Back," per Paper.
Why it matters: This is the one case here where the company did not apologize, so it tests the opposite approach. In EPR's reading, the sourced record shows a defended ad, a share-price drop and a third party's spoof owning the conversation. The record does not show a recovery, so Peloton belongs in this list as a contrast, not as a model.
How did Johnson & Johnson handle the 1982 Tylenol crisis?
Johnson & Johnson recalled about 31 million bottles of Tylenol at a cost of $100 million after seven people died in the Chicago area in 1982. Knowledge at Wharton reports that Tylenol held 35% of a $1.2 billion analgesic market before the deaths, fell to 7% afterward, and relaunched two months later in tamper-proof packaging.
The recovery was documented too. Wharton reports Tylenol's share climbed back to 30% by mid-1983 and reached 35% by the end of that year. The Daily Herald says the company introduced first-ever triple-seal tamper-resistant packaging and credits its credo, and Burke said in a Wharton article that the credo helped him persuade shareholders to spend the $100 million. This is a recall response, not an apology ad, but it shows the same rule: the admission was an action. See EPR's Tylenol crisis case study.
How did JetBlue apologize after its 2007 meltdown?
JetBlue's founder and CEO David Neeleman apologized publicly and launched a Customer Bill of Rights after a Valentine's Day 2007 ice storm stranded passengers. CNN Money reported that Neeleman put the cost at about $30 million, made up of about $10 million for refunds, $16 million for vouchers and $4 million in incremental costs.
NBC News reported that Neeleman quickly and publicly acknowledged the airline's mistakes, and that under the new policy a customer could ask for a refund, credit or voucher if JetBlue canceled a flight within 12 hours of departure for reasons within its control, in its coverage. Time described a weeklong media apology tour from the Today show to David Letterman to Anderson Cooper, and Knowledge at Wharton adds a full-page newspaper apology and says he never blamed the weather.
The outcome was mixed. The Boston Globe reports Neeleman resigned as chief executive in 2007 under pressure from the board, while Wharton describes the Customer Bill of Rights as the industry's first.
How do the five cases compare?
The five cases differ in what failed and what the company did, and only some have a documented recovery. The table lists the sourced facts for each.
| Case | Year | What failed | Response | Documented outcome |
| Domino's | 2009 to 2010 | Pizza quality | On-camera admission plus new recipe | Same-store sales up 14.3% in Q1 2010 |
| KFC | 2018 | UK chicken supply | Full-page "FCK" apology | 733 articles carried the image, per the agency |
| Peloton | 2019 | Holiday ad reception | Statement defending the ad | Stock fell; spoof ad followed |
| Johnson & Johnson | 1982 | Poisoned capsules | 31 million bottle recall, tamper-proof packaging | Share fell to 7%, back to 35% by end of 1983 |
| JetBlue | 2007 | Stranded passengers | Apology and Customer Bill of Rights | $30 million cost; CEO resigned |
What is the timeline of these apologies?
The timeline runs from 1982 to 2019. The table dates each moment from its source.
| Date | Moment | Company |
| September 1982 | Seven deaths in the Chicago area; recall of about 31 million bottles | Johnson & Johnson |
| February 14 to 20, 2007 | Ice-storm meltdown; Customer Bill of Rights announced February 20 | JetBlue |
| December 27, 2009 | "Pizza Turnaround" launches in the US | Domino's |
| Q1 2010 | Same-store sales up 14.3% | Domino's |
| February 23, 2018 | "FCK" ad runs in The Sun and Metro | KFC UK |
| December 2019 | Holiday ad backlash; Aviation Gin spoof on December 7 | Peloton |
The format matters because audiences judge whether an apology names the specific thing that went wrong. In EPR's reading, Domino's and KFC used blunt, specific language, while JetBlue's Customer Bill of Rights turned an apology into a written commitment with a dollar figure attached. A specific admission signals the company understands the failure, and a vague one signals someone wrote around it. This pattern shows up across EPR's crisis communications coverage and its guide to crisis communications failure patterns.
What should an apology checklist include?
An apology checklist should force the company to name the failure, take responsibility and attach an action. The steps below follow the pattern in the five cases, and they are EPR's editorial synthesis, not a legal standard. Use them in order:
- Name the specific failure in plain language, as Domino's and KFC did.
- Say who is responsible, and do not blame circumstances, as Wharton notes JetBlue's CEO avoided blaming the weather.
- Attach an action the audience can verify: a new recipe, a recall, a written compensation policy.
- Put a senior executive in front of the message, as Domino's president and JetBlue's CEO did.
- Tell people where to get current information, as KFC did with a microsite.
- Decide in advance whether to apologize or defend, because Peloton shows the cost of defending a widely criticized ad.
What do these campaigns have in common?
The cases that show a documented recovery paired the admission with a real change: a reformulated recipe, a recall and new packaging, a compensation policy. In EPR's reading, the specific, early admission mattered more than the size of the media budget. The one case that defended the ad is the one without a documented recovery. For wider reading, see EPR's consumer brand stories and marketing scandals from 2024 to 2026.
Sources
- WARC, Domino's: Pizza Turnaround (Cannes case entry)
- Columbia Business School, Domino's wins by eating a little humble pie
- AOL Daily Finance, new pizza brings Domino's huge sales gains
- Nation's Restaurant News, top marketing trends of 2010
- PMQ, new pizza recipe did wonders for Domino's sales
- NACS, Self-deprecation pays dividends for Domino's
- CNBC, KFC issues tongue-in-cheek apology
- Marketing Week, KFC uses cheeky print advert to apologise
- It's Nice That, Mother London creates fowl mouthed apology advert for KFC
- Yahoo News, KFC says FCK in full-page ad
- The One Club, FCK (One Show 2019)
- HuffPost via Yahoo, Ryan Reynolds recruits woman from the Peloton ad
- BuzzFeed News, the Peloton wife is in a new ad
- Good Morning America, actor from controversial Peloton ad speaks out
- The Fly, Peloton defends holiday ad
- Paper, Peloton Aviation Gin Monica Ruiz
- Knowledge at Wharton, James Burke and the Tylenol crisis
- Knowledge at Wharton, Tylenol and the legacy of J&J's James Burke
- Daily Herald, Tylenol and tamper-resistant packaging
- CNN Money, JetBlue fiasco: $30M price tag
- NBC News, JetBlue's fate rests in living up to promises
- Time, the new world of crisis management
- Knowledge at Wharton, JetBlue's apology
- Boston Globe, carrier to bring Boston-Lisbon flights to Logan
Related: Marketing campaigns · Best marketing campaigns · Crisis communications · KFC FCK apology ad · Domino's turnaround · Tylenol crisis of 1982