Public relations turned authenticity into a billable deliverable over the past decade, which is why AI-generated brand content now sounds like the human-written brand content it learned from. Mary Pedler, Founder of INPUT Global, argues that AI only copied templates PR agencies already produced, and that brands earn trust by doing something first, then showing how they did it and disclosing any use of AI.
Every weekday morning brings another wave of near-identical founder letters and "honest" posts about how tough the year has been: founders' out-of-cash nights, teams' unpolished office clips, and brands' "mistakes" that look suspiciously like product teasers.
Everyone in my industry wants to sound authentic, and somehow everyone ends up sounding identical.
In a Gartner survey from September, 57% of consumers say AI-generated content has made them less trusting of brand messaging overall. Roughly two-thirds also believe companies are pumping far too much AI material into their marketing.
Most of my working days go to fintech, Web3, and AI founders. Nearly every brief lately asks for something "authentic," and very few of those briefs describe anything the company has done.
Blaming the machines feels convenient, though I think the PR industry deserves a bigger share of the responsibility. PR spent the last decade turning authenticity into a deliverable, and AI made that deliverable cheaper to copy. The models learned how a brand should sound mostly from us.
Authenticity turned into a neat section of agency proposals between media training and award submissions. Brands began briefing us for "raw" and "unfiltered" content with the same rigor they apply to product launches.
"Community," "transparency," "purpose," and "being human" appear in almost identical sentences across entire sectors. Vulnerability follows the same pattern, in the founder's carefully timed post about burnout and the unboxing filmed to look accidental.
Our own measurement habits made things worse, since coverage reports still celebrate the number of placements over what any of them said. Copying a release across fifty sites looks impressive on a dashboard.
Brands take up a cause for a quarter and quietly drop it once the campaign wraps. People remember these exits long after the launch post fades.
Even crisis apologies now arrive in a familiar shape, complete with a soft opening, a vague "we hear you," and a promise to do better.
A review of company announcements from this autumn found the same fatigue in corporate quotes, especially when executives talked about innovation, growth, or customer experience. Those quotes mostly repeated the press release. I like the review's test for this: could a competitor say the same sentence?
Executive quotes resurfaced in 39 of 52 articles in one recent coverage sample, and only 2 of those pieces contained original reporting.
Consumers read these signals better than our industry likes to admit. Clutch found that 59% name generic or robotic messaging among the fastest ways a brand loses their trust.
AI Exposes Cracks That Were Already There
Generative tools inherited that sameness and then scaled it. Feed a model a thousand polished brand statements, and the thousand-and-first it hands back will be fluent and forgettable.
Gartner also found that 35% of consumers rely on influencers less for shopping advice because of AI-generated content. Even the channel PR once used to borrow credibility is losing its appeal.
Undisclosed AI or synthetic media is the top reason for losing trust in a brand, according to 43% of US consumers, ahead of disguised sponsorships and dubious influencer partnerships.
I find it uncomfortable how little AI has changed about our habits. We were already recycling templates, approving interchangeable quotes, and calling it storytelling long before the first prompt. Machines just made the emptiness easier to spot.
Journalists feel it first, because their inboxes fill with pitches that sound as though a single author wrote them all. Nobody gets remembered when every founder is "thrilled to announce" a "mission-driven" product.
A sponsored post that reads like a brand script drains the creator's credibility along with the brand's. Audiences follow creators for their judgment, and a scripted voice spends that judgment fast.
Taking Authenticity off the Campaign Calendar
Authenticity shouldn't be a campaign KPI or a tone the agency switches on when the client asks for it. I keep telling founders that a message gets stronger the moment it gets more honest. Honesty starts with decisions made far from the comms team.
Emplifi found that consumers point to search results and user-generated content as their top authenticity signals. Both live outside a brand's direct control, so the brand has to behave well and let people talk.
Getting this right also pays off commercially. The same survey found that 85% of consumers are willing to pay extra for brands they see as authentic. Showing how a product is made earns credibility.
Brands should also let customers see the unflattering parts, like a delayed feature or a pricing mistake, and explain what happens next. Owning a small misstep in public can build the trust a dozen polished posts never earned.
Disclosing AI use is the cheapest trust insurance a brand can buy, since a simple label on synthetic visuals or drafted copy costs almost nothing.
Teams can still use AI for research, transcription, and rough drafts, but someone with real expertise has the final word. Audiences seem comfortable with machines doing the legwork, and they push back when a machine starts doing the talking.
Executives can help by talking the way they do in a good board meeting, with specific problems, real trade-offs, and honest admissions. Clients sometimes worry this sounds unpolished, yet journalists are likelier to quote a line that explains a decision.
Media relations deserve the same honesty, which starts with giving reporters time and real access. Someone higher up should be there to answer any awkward questions. Founders rush announcements out through paid distribution and get volume, but the stories that move a market rarely come from wire copy.
Above all, a brand has to do the thing before it posts about the thing.
Trust Gets Built Off-Camera
Our industry still holds real influence over how companies speak, and the stakes are too high to spend it on another round of carefully staged honesty. I would love to see PR agencies push clients toward evidence. Every proposal promising authenticity should come with a plan for what the brand will change, publish, or prove.
My advice to founders: say what you did, then show how you did it. Label what a machine produced, and let customers do the storytelling. Brands willing to live with a little less polish will find that people start listening again.