| Public buyer | Final award | Winner | Winner's evaluated price | Lowest eligible price | Price rank | Premium |
| Bi-State Development, Missouri and Illinois | April 19, 2024 | Osborn & Barr Communications | $811,000 | $618,000 | 3 of 4 | 31.2% |
| City of Trenton, New Jersey | November 7, 2024 | EFK, LLC | $82,000 | $42,000 | 2 of 3 | 95.2% |
| Camden County Municipal Utilities Authority, New Jersey | November 18, 2024 | Clearbridge Branding Agency | $97,020 | $78,677 | 4 of 6 | 23.3% |
| Fire Island Union Free School District, New York | May 13, 2025 | ZE Creative Communications | $30,000 | $28,600 | 2 of 2 | 4.9% |
| City of Clifton, New Jersey | September 16, 2025 | Triad Associates, Inc. | $50,000 annually | $50,000 annually | Tied 1st of 3 | 0.0% |
The winner ranked first technically in the one competition that published technical scores, which was the Bi-State Development award. The series describes five records, so it cannot establish a nationwide win rate or show that price caused an award.
How did the Gateway Arch contract go to the top technical score?
Bi-State Development awarded the Gateway Arch and Riverboats PR and communications contract to Osborn & Barr Communications on April 19, 2024, because the firm earned the highest combined technical and cost score, even though its price ranked third of four. Evaluators scored four firms for a five-year assignment on a common 1,000-hour pricing basis. The board's April 19 minutes and Resolution 1335 identify Osborn & Barr as the highest-ranked firm.
| Firm | Evaluated price, 1,000 hours | Technical points | Price points | Overall points |
| Osborn & Barr Communications | $811,000 | 285 | 95.25 | 380.25 |
| The Hauser Group | $618,000 | 249.17 | 125 | 374.17 |
| Common Ground Public Relations | $735,000 | 268.75 | 105.10 | 373.85 |
| Lambert Global | $1,265,000 | 230 | 61.07 | 291.07 |
The published numbers show how the trade-off worked. The Hauser Group earned 29.75 more price points than Osborn & Barr, and Osborn & Barr earned 35.83 more technical points, a net margin of 6.08 points. Everything-PR's arithmetic on the table also shows that each price score equals the lowest price divided by the firm's price, times 125.
After scoring, Bi-State obtained a $1,013,750 best-and-final offer from Osborn & Barr for 1,250 hours, and the board authorized up to $1,115,125 including contingency. The 31.2% premium comes from the 1,000-hour scores in the board briefing. Because only the top-ranked firm submitted the revised offer, the record provides no same-scope premium for the negotiated award.
What did Trenton's council record show about EFK?
Trenton's council approved EFK, LLC on November 7, 2024, at $82,000 for one year of PR, marketing and consulting for the mayor's office and the fire and police departments, which was $40,000 above the lowest eligible bid. Fuerza Strategy Group quoted $42,000, and Touch of Culture Marketing quoted $420,000 on the revised tabulation.
The city's revised opening sheet marks one proposal, from Success Communications Group at $300,000, as disqualified, and an earlier sheet flagged a second. EFK ranks second by price under either version. Resolution 24-449 cites EFK's qualifications and expertise at the budgeted rates, and the city did not disclose technical scores.
The council minutes spell the winner EKF, while the resolution, funding certification and opening sheet use EFK.
What do the Camden County and Fire Island records show?
Camden County Municipal Utilities Authority awarded Clearbridge Branding Agency a one-year marketing and public communication contract at $97,020, the fourth-lowest of six submitted prices. The lowest submission, listed as Raffelis, was $78,677, so the winner's bid was $18,343 higher. Three bids sat within $880 of each other, at $96,140, $96,600 and $97,020.
The review committee found that Clearbridge's proposal met its technical, management and cost requirements, according to the adopted resolution. The resolution supplies no separate technical scores. A 2026 competition at the same authority also went to Clearbridge, at $60,000 among eight bidders, though that record lists no rival prices.
Fire Island Union Free School District accepted ZE Creative Communications at $30,000 over Syntax Communication at $28,600 for 2025-26 PR services, a $1,400 and 4.9% difference. The board voted 6-0 on the superintendent's recommendation, per the May 13, 2025 minutes. The minutes record no technical scores, option-year prices or specific rationale.
What happened in Clifton when two firms bid the same price?
The City of Clifton received three responsive and responsible proposals for a combined grant writing and PR contract. Triad and Bruno both quoted $50,000 annually. Clifton selected Triad, and the resolution cites its successful prior service. Millenium Strategies quoted $57,000.
The council acted on September 16, 2025, in Resolution 467-25. The resolution prints conflicting end dates, so the comparison uses the annual amounts the city published for all three firms, per the September 16 meeting minutes. Clifton is the one case in the series where the winner tied for the lowest price.
What do the five records say about price and qualifications?
Each of the five public records states a different basis for the selection, ranging from combined scores to a superintendent's recommendation. The wording in the records shows how varied those bases were.
- Bi-State's resolution named Osborn & Barr the highest-ranked firm on combined technical and cost scores.
- Trenton's resolution cited EFK's qualifications and expertise at the budgeted rates.
- Camden County's committee found Clearbridge met its technical, management and cost requirements.
- Fire Island's minutes recorded the superintendent's recommendation, with no further reason.
- Clifton's resolution cited Triad's successful prior service.
Premiums in the four higher-priced awards ran from 4.9% to 95.2%, with a middle pair at 23.3% and 31.2%. Price clearly mattered in the one case that published scores, since Bi-State's formula gave the lowest bidder 125 price points. It did not decide the outcome there, because technical points carried a margin of up to 375.
How can bidders and buyers read these results?
Bidders and buyers can read a public PR award best by checking four items in the record before comparing prices. The case series suggests that each item changed what a price comparison meant.
- Confirm the pricing basis. Bi-State scored on 1,000 hours and then negotiated 1,250 hours, and Clifton compared annual amounts despite conflicting end dates.
- Check whether technical scores were published. Only one of five buyers released them.
- Read the stated reason in the resolution, such as qualifications, expertise or prior service.
- Count eligible bidders and disqualifications. Trenton's three eligible firms and one disqualification shaped its price rank.
Buyers can make future comparisons easier by publishing technical scores and the price basis beside each award. Agencies tracking open opportunities can use the government PR RFP directory and the PR and marketing RFP hub. Pricing context for the wider sample sits in the public PR contract audit and the public PR RFP scoring audit.
Why are Maine and Nashville outside the count?
Maine and Nashville are outside the count because the Maine final award could not be dated and the Nashville procurement falls before the study window. The exclusions show the verification standard behind the five included cases.
Maine's evaluation packet for the lottery marketing, advertising and PR RFP ranks Fuseideas first of six scored firms, at $1,312,500, with 67 technical points, 25 price points and 92 overall. The dated notice in the packet, August 27, 2025, was conditional on final approval and successful negotiation, and a final award or executed agreement tied to the solicitation was not verified. Nashville's RFQ 1039699 entries are dated October 23, 2018, outside the January 1, 2024, to November 19, 2026 window.
How did Everything-PR verify the awards?
Everything-PR verified each award against buyer-published records and required a dated final approval, a common price basis and a competitive single-winner decision. A budget, authorization ceiling or price score did not stand in for a bidder's price.
Search trail and inclusion rules
The search began with the Everything-PR public PR contract audit and scoring audit, then followed leads through state procurement portals, local board records, school district minutes and public authority bid archives. A second pass added targeted searches for proposal opening sheets, purchasing registers, adopted resolutions and contract notices across state, municipal, school, transit, airport and utility archives. The workbook logs 53 other records and the reason each stayed outside the count.
The price premium is the difference between the winner's evaluated price and the lowest eligible evaluated price, divided by the lowest eligible evaluated price. Where a final comparative offer governed competitive selection, the audit used it. Three of the five verified competitions came from New Jersey. The series fell below the 10-competition threshold for a broader audit, so public disclosure determined which competitions could be compared.