The Peloton Christmas commercial, "The Gift That Gives Back," drew a wave of sexism and privilege criticism in early December 2019, and Peloton's stock fell more than 9% on December 3, erasing $942 million of market value in a day. Peloton defended the ad instead of pulling it, and its holiday quarter showed revenue up 77% and subscribers up 96%.
What happened with the Peloton Christmas commercial?
Peloton ran a 30-second holiday spot in which a woman receives a Peloton bike from her husband and spends the next year filming herself riding it, according to Awful Announcing's report on the reaction. The ad debuted in early November 2019 and reached a wide audience over the Thanksgiving weekend.
Bloomberg's report in Fortune said critics on social media read the ad as implying the woman was being pressured to keep her weight in check. CNN reported that users also called the spot deaf to the privilege of the people in it.
The ad itself carried no news event. The story came from how viewers read 30 seconds of footage, and how quickly that reading moved from social media to the stock price.
Who was involved in the case?
Four named parties shaped the Peloton case: the company, the actress, a celebrity-owned brand and the analyst who watched the stock.
| Party | Role | Part in the case |
| Peloton Interactive | Connected-fitness company, Nasdaq: PTON | Defended the ad and kept it running |
| Monica Ruiz | Actress who played the wife | Became widely known as the "Peloton wife" and later starred in a parody ad |
| Ryan Reynolds | Actor and part owner of Aviation Gin | Released a parody ad starring Ruiz within days |
| Justin Patterson | Analyst at Raymond James | Said Peloton's response was worth monitoring and expected the ad to be pulled |
How did the backlash unfold, step by step?
The Peloton backlash moved from social media to the share price in about a week and drew a celebrity parody within days.
| Date | Event | Why it mattered |
| Early November 2019 | The holiday ad debuts | It ran for weeks before the backlash peaked |
| Thanksgiving weekend 2019 | Viewers see the ad during sports coverage and social media criticism builds | Heavy exposure turned a niche reaction into a mainstream one |
| December 3, 2019 | Peloton shares fall more than 9%, a $942 million loss of market value, according to Business Insider | The reputation story became a market story |
| December 4, 2019 | Peloton issues a statement defending the ad. Reynolds' team contacts Ruiz that morning | The company chose to defend the creative, and a competitor in attention began work on a parody |
| December 6, 2019 | Aviation Gin releases "The Gift That Doesn't Give Back" with Ruiz | A third party took over the second act of the story |
| February 5, 2020 | Peloton reports results for the quarter ended December 31, 2019 | The business results answered the question the stock drop had raised |
How did Peloton respond, and did it work?
Peloton defended the ad instead of withdrawing it, and the company's holiday-quarter results showed no visible sales damage.
A Peloton spokesperson said the company constantly hears from members whose lives were positively affected by owning a Peloton, according to InsideHook's report on the share drop. In a second statement reported by CNBC and CNN, the company said it was disappointed that some had misinterpreted the spot and that it was created to celebrate a fitness and wellness journey.
Raymond James analyst Justin Patterson told Bloomberg on December 4 that he expected the ad to be pulled and that the controversy would fade after the late-night parodies. The ad stayed, and the numbers support the second half of his view. Peloton's second-quarter shareholder letter reported revenue of $466.3 million, up 77%, and 712,005 Connected Fitness subscribers, up 96%, with average net monthly churn of 0.74%.
InsideHook, citing Fortune, reported that the stock was up about 20% from its late December dip and that search interest in the brand had risen.
What did the parody show about response speed?
The parody showed that a third party can write the second act of a crisis within two days if the brand under pressure does not engage with the story.
Ryan Reynolds and his Aviation Gin partners contacted Ruiz on Wednesday, December 4, and released the ad on Friday, December 6, according to Boston.com's report. Reynolds said they had to move quickly while the social media reaction was still running. The ad never names Peloton, but Reynolds' caption, "Exercise bike not included," made the reference plain, as VinePair's coverage of the ad describes.
Ruiz also spoke publicly. She told the TODAY show that some of the criticism may have come from her facial expression, and she said she was grateful to both Peloton and Aviation Gin for the work, according to TODAY's interview report.
Was the Peloton commercial really a PR disaster?
The Peloton commercial was a reputation event with a one-day financial cost, and it was not a lasting sales disaster on the available evidence.
| Measure | Result | Source |
| Stock move on December 3, 2019 | Down more than 9%, a $942 million loss of market value | Business Insider, via InsideHook |
| Quarter ended December 31, 2019, revenue | $466.3 million, up 77% | Peloton shareholder letter |
| Connected Fitness subscribers | 712,005, up 96% | Peloton shareholder letter |
| Average net monthly churn | 0.74% | Peloton shareholder letter |
| Stock after the late December dip | Up about 20% by early February 2020 | InsideHook, citing Fortune |
The label "disaster" fits the speed and the volume of the criticism. It fits the financial outcome less well, and the case is a useful reminder that a viral reaction and a business result can move in different directions. Peloton's later reputation challenges are covered in the Peloton communications and turnaround reference.
What can communicators take from the Peloton case?
Communicators can take four controls from the Peloton case, each tied to a specific failure point.
| Failure point | What happened | Control that addresses it |
| Creative tested for intent, not for reading | Viewers read pressure and privilege into a 30-second spot meant to celebrate a fitness journey | Show the finished ad to viewers who do not know the intent and ask for the least generous reasonable reading |
| Response framed the audience as wrong | The company said some people had misinterpreted the ad | Acknowledge how the ad was read before explaining what it was meant to say |
| Social volume not tied to investor communications | The share price fell before the company's statement | Set a trigger that alerts investor relations when social volume on a campaign passes a set level |
| No plan for parody | A parody ad took the story over within two days | Decide in advance whether the brand will engage with parody, and who approves a reply |
For other creative-review failures and recoveries, see the Balenciaga ad scandal case study and the Bud Light boycott recovery case. For the frameworks behind them, see the crisis communications pillar and the reputation management pillar.
What is the lesson of the Peloton case in one sentence?
The Peloton case shows that a campaign's meaning is set by its audience and not by its makers, so the response has to start from how the work was read. A team can use the table above as a pre-launch check: if outside viewers read the ad differently from the brief, the ad is not ready, however strong the sales forecast.