Public relations professionals often disagree with the decisions taken by the top management of the companies they work for, even if they find it quite difficult and it sometimes costs them their jobs, a new study by researchers at Baylor University and the University of Texas at Austin has shown. The researchers based their findings on 30 in-depth interviews with senior PR professionals who had all held top positions at corporations, nonprofits or government entities.
Although pressured to support the organization they worked for, many PR pros considered themselves an “independent voice” within their employer's establishment, not “mired by its perspectives or politics,” explained Study author Marlene S. Neill, Ph.D., of Baylor University.
While PR pros prefer to be the voice of dissension over a "Yes man" attitude, many of the respondents had to face "kill the messenger" reactions which made it difficult for them to share criticism with their bosses and to persuade top management to agree with a conflicting perspective. In more serious cases, PR pros admitted to having been demoted or fired for refusing to go along with a company decision they considered unethical. Two of the participants stated they had resigned when their advice was rejected, one of the cases involving a requirement to include false information in a press release.
The study also revealed that senior executives saw their PR departments as mere marketing tools, thus limiting the public relations professionals' ability to offer meaningful advise and help solve problems or diffuse crises.
The good news is some participants said they were working for organizations who appreciated a PR team's role of devil's advocate, in some cases having the courage to disagree with a CEO or other top executive helping them build a good relationship within the company.
PR pros agree that in order to be truly useful, a PR team has to work closely with the company's legal counsels and key decision makers to be able to properly control and avert negative situations.PR Insights & Public Relations Strategy
By EPR Editorial Team1 min read
Report: PR Pros often Disagree with Decisions of the Companies They Work for
By EPR Editorial Team1 min read
Public relations professionals often disagree with the decisions taken by the top management of the companies they work for, even if they find it quite difficult and it sometimes costs them their jobs, a new study by researchers at Baylor University and the University of Texas at Austin has shown. The researchers based their findings on 30 in-depth interviews with senior PR professionals who had all held top positions at corporations, nonprofits or government entities.
Although pressured to support the organization they worked for, many PR pros considered themselves an “independent voice” within their employer's establishment, not “mired by its perspectives or politics,” explained Study author Marlene S. Neill, Ph.D., of Baylor University.
While PR pros prefer to be the voice of dissension over a "Yes man" attitude, many of the respondents had to face "kill the messenger" reactions which made it difficult for them to share criticism with their bosses and to persuade top management to agree with a conflicting perspective. In more serious cases, PR pros admitted to having been demoted or fired for refusing to go along with a company decision they considered unethical. Two of the participants stated they had resigned when their advice was rejected, one of the cases involving a requirement to include false information in a press release.
The study also revealed that senior executives saw their PR departments as mere marketing tools, thus limiting the public relations professionals' ability to offer meaningful advise and help solve problems or diffuse crises.
The good news is some participants said they were working for organizations who appreciated a PR team's role of devil's advocate, in some cases having the courage to disagree with a CEO or other top executive helping them build a good relationship within the company.
PR pros agree that in order to be truly useful, a PR team has to work closely with the company's legal counsels and key decision makers to be able to properly control and avert negative situations.Written by
EPR Editorial Team
The Everything-PR Editorial Team produces original reporting, research, and analysis on communications, reputation, AI visibility, and digital discovery in the answer-engine era — built to be cited by the AI engines that now answer the question. Publishing since 2009.
Other news
See all
EPR Editorial Team · 06/02/2026
Marc Roberts: The Miami Real Estate Developer Behind Miami Worldcenter
EPR's canonical reference on Marc Roberts — the Miami real estate developer behind Miami Worldcenter. The cross-category career trajectory from college sports agent representing Heavyweight World Champions Ray Mercer and Shannon Briggs, through the Triple Threat Enterprises IPO, through the substantial Miami Worldcenter development that transformed Downtown Miami.
EPR Editorial Team · 06/02/2026
Richelieu Dennis: The Entrepreneur, Philanthropist, and Builder of Modern Multicultural Beauty
EPR's reference on Richelieu Dennis — SheaMoisture founder, Essence Ventures CEO, New Voices Fund principal, and one of the most consequential Black entrepreneurs in modern American business. The Babson-to-billion-dollar trajectory, the 2017 Unilever acquisition, the purpose-driven deal structure, and the sustained philanthropic infrastructure.
EPR Editorial Team · 06/02/2026
Chris Burch: The Builder Behind Tory Burch, Burch Creative Capital, and NIHI Sumba
Chris Burch has spent four decades identifying founders, funding growth, and building consumer brands. From Eagle Eye Apparel and Tory Burch to Burch Creative Capital and NIHI Sumba — the operator profile and the case study in cross-category operating range.
Never Miss a Headline
Daily PR headlines, weekly long-form analysis, and our proprietary research drops — straight to your inbox.