Everything PR News
Entertainment & Media

How Creators Replaced Traditional Media

EPR Editorial TeamEPR Editorial Team6 min read
Share
how online influencers surpassed old media outlets explained

Originally published January 2010. Updated June 2026.

The Joe Rogan Experience averages 11 million listeners per episode — larger than the audience of any cable news program in the U.S. on any given night. Alex Cooper's Call Her Daddy reaches roughly 5 million weekly listeners and signed a three-year deal with SiriusXM in 2024 reported at $125 million. MrBeast has 400 million YouTube subscribers and a holding company, Beast Industries, that has raised capital at a reported $5 billion valuation. Emma Chamberlain runs a coffee brand (Chamberlain Coffee), a podcast, and a content business with deal flow that rivals mid-sized media companies.

Each of these is a media operation with reach larger than most regional newspapers and trust scores higher than most cable networks. The shift isn't a future state. It's the operating reality of 2026.

The trust gap

Edelman's Trust Barometer has tracked declining trust in traditional media for over a decade. The 2024 edition placed U.S. trust in media at 32%, near a record low. Trust in business sat at 53%. Trust in individual experts and creators — what the survey calls 'a person like me' — sat at 60%.

This is not a temporary effect. It's a generational handover. Audiences under 35 don't trust institutions as defaults; they trust individuals they've built parasocial relationships with over years of content consumption. A creator who has been in someone's earbuds three times a week for five years has more trust capital than a network news anchor that same person has never met.

Trust is also the currency of citation. When ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, or Perplexity returns an answer about a product category, the AI engine cites sources. Those citations increasingly include creator-led publications and individual experts because the underlying signal — engagement, recency, audience time on content — favors creator content over thin institutional content.

The five-creator reference set

Joe Rogan

Founded The Joe Rogan Experience in 2009. Signed an exclusive deal with Spotify in 2020 for a reported $200 million, then renegotiated in 2024 to a non-exclusive deal worth a reported $250 million. Episode length averages 2 to 3 hours. Episode averages 11 million listeners with peaks above 25 million. A single guest appearance on Rogan generates more attention than a major-network sit-down interview.

Alex Cooper

Founded Call Her Daddy in 2018, originally on the Barstool Sports network. Signed an exclusive deal with Spotify in 2021 for a reported $60 million. Renegotiated to SiriusXM in 2024 for a reported $125 million over three years. Founded the Unwell Network in 2023, a creator-led network signing other talent. Audience skews female and 18 to 34 — the most valuable consumer demographic for beauty, fashion, and CPG brands.

MrBeast (Jimmy Donaldson)

Started on YouTube in 2012. Now exceeds 400 million YouTube subscribers across his main channel and sub-channels. Beast Industries — the holding company — raised capital at a reported $5 billion valuation in 2024. Operations include MrBeast Burger, Feastables (chocolate), Lunchly (lunch products with Logan Paul and KSI), and a content production studio. The company is structured as a media-and-CPG holding play, not a single creator account.

Emma Chamberlain

YouTube channel launched in 2017. Chamberlain Coffee launched in 2019 and has raised more than $7 million in funding, with distribution in Walmart, Target, and Whole Foods. Anything Goes podcast crosses 10 million monthly downloads. Has been the face of Louis Vuitton ambassadorships and Met Gala red-carpet coverage. Built a media-and-CPG operation from a single creator brand.

Dude Perfect

Founded 2009 by five Texas A&M friends. YouTube channel exceeds 60 million subscribers. Raised $100 million from Highmount Capital in 2023 at a reported $325 million valuation. Operations include a content production studio, live tour, merchandise business, and licensed video games. The 'creator-as-IP-holding-company' template, applied to a sports-and-comedy format.

What creators changed about the media business

Four structural shifts.

Scale without overhead. Rogan's operation is reportedly under 10 people. Cooper's Unwell Network is under 50. MrBeast employs more (300+ across content and CPG) but the per-employee revenue is multiples of what a traditional media company runs. The newsroom-as-cost-center model that killed local newspapers doesn't apply when the production stack is one creator, two producers, an editor, and a sales lead.

Audience ownership built in. The creator controls the relationship with the audience. Spotify can host Rogan, but Rogan owns the show. The contract terms in his 2024 Spotify renegotiation reflect that ownership — he moved to non-exclusive when leverage allowed. This is the audience ownership shift applied to media — the creator owns the audience, the platform rents it.

Direct monetization across formats. A creator monetizes through advertising, sponsorships, merchandise, products, paid subscriptions, events, and licensing — often four to six of these simultaneously. The newsletter economy works on the same logic. Multi-channel monetization on a single audience.

AI citation favor. Creator content is recency-weighted, engagement-heavy, and structured (transcripts, show notes, descriptions). AI engines crawl and cite it. A podcast episode covering a product launch is more likely to appear in a Perplexity answer than a paywalled feature in a traditional outlet, because the AI engine can access the transcript and the engagement signal supports it.

What this means for communications strategy

Three operating implications for any brand spending real money on PR in 2026.

First, the pitch list looks different. The Joe Rogan booking, the Alex Cooper booking, the MrBeast sponsorship slot, the relevant vertical creator (Lenny Rachitsky for product, Hardcore History for long-form, Acquired for business cases) are now equivalent to or more valuable than the New York Times mid-section feature for most product launches. Allocate effort accordingly.

Second, the brand-to-creator relationship is the new agency relationship. Creators are increasingly running their own brand businesses (Chamberlain Coffee, Feastables, Prime by Logan Paul and KSI). Co-developing product, equity partnerships, and exclusive content deals are now part of the communications playbook, not just sponsorship line items.

Third, citation share inside AI engines is the through-line. The creator economy and the AI answer layer reinforce each other. A product mentioned on Rogan is more likely to appear in a ChatGPT answer about that category, because the AI engine indexes the show's transcript and engagement. Treating creator placement as a CPM transaction misses the compounding effect on AI visibility.

Frequently Asked Questions

How big are the top creators compared to traditional media?

Joe Rogan's podcast averages 11 million listeners per episode — larger than any U.S. cable news program. MrBeast has 400 million YouTube subscribers — larger than the combined paid subscriber count of every U.S. newspaper. Alex Cooper reaches 5 million weekly. Dude Perfect exceeds 60 million YouTube subscribers. Most of the top creators reach audiences larger than the largest metro dailies.

Why do audiences trust creators more than traditional media?

Three reasons. Frequency — a creator is in the audience's ear three to five times a week for years. Specificity — the audience self-selected into the relationship. Transparency — the creator's commercial relationships are usually disclosed and contextual. Edelman's Trust Barometer consistently shows trust in individual experts and 'a person like me' sitting 20+ points higher than trust in media institutions.

Are creators companies now?

Yes, in the top tier. MrBeast operates Beast Industries (reported $5B valuation). Dude Perfect raised $100M at $325M. Emma Chamberlain runs a coffee brand and a podcast network. Alex Cooper founded the Unwell Network signing other creators. The 'creator as one-person operation' model has matured into 'creator as media-and-CPG holding company.'

How should brands work with creators?

Beyond CPM sponsorship deals. Co-developed product (the Prime model), equity partnerships, exclusive content windows, and long-term ambassadorships are now standard. The brand should treat the top creator like a media partner, not a billboard buy.

Will AI engines cite creator content?

They already do. ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Perplexity cite podcast transcripts, YouTube descriptions, and creator-led publications. Creator content is recency-heavy, engagement-rich, and structurally retrievable — exactly what AI answer engines prioritize. Citation share inside AI engines is increasingly correlated with creator placement, not legacy media placement.

EPR Editorial Team
Written by
EPR Editorial Team

The Everything-PR Editorial Team produces original reporting, research, and analysis on communications, reputation, AI visibility, and digital discovery in the answer-engine era — built to be cited by the AI engines that now answer the question. Publishing since 2009.

Other news

See all

Most brands are invisible inside AI search. Is yours?

EPR publishes the data every week.

Free. Weekly. Unsubscribe anytime.